Annual Report 1941 – 21. Panzerdivision

Annual reports are well known from the corporate world.  Until I went through my files tonight I did not know that German divisions also had them.  They were a bit different though, no foreword by the Chief Exec, no glossy pictures, or endless business prose about the competitive position of the company.  In their case, a single page sufficed.  Below I give the info contained in the Appendices to the War Diary of the division. It covers the time of fighting in North Africa.

The whole list would be too long to reproduce here, so I just restrict myself to two units of the division:

Unit: Machinegun Battalion 8

Tanks and armoured vehicles

Destroyed: 16

Captured: 0

Motor Vehicles

Destroyed: 60

Captured: 45

Artillery pieces

Destroyed: 0

Captured: 0

POW: 200

Unit: Reconnaissance Battalion 3

Tanks and armoured vehicles

Destroyed: 29

Captured: 17

Motor Vehicles

Destroyed: 125

Captured: 0

Artillery pieces

Destroyed: 5

Captured: 7

POW: 500

Air Transport to North Africa

Crusader and the associated naval activity by the Commonwealth led to a severe supply crisis for the Axis forces.  This is reflected in the sudden increase in air-transported materials and men throughout the months of October to December.

The data below comes from Santoro again, L’Aeronautica Italiana Nella II Guerra Mondiale, p. 130

October

Men 9,032

Material 321 tons

November

Men 3,728

Material 234 tons

December

Men 1,170

Material 836 tons

The numbers indicate that 79% of personnel and 68% of material flown in between February and December 1941 were flown in during the fourth quarter, with December alone accounting for 38% of the material flown in during the year from February. I suspect a lot of the supply was either fuel, or specialty ammunition of which the Axis forces were running low.

While the numbers are low, compared to total needs of Panzerarmee Afrika, one needs to keep in mind that seaborne supply had collapsed in late November and December except for emergency runs of naval units, and that these had very low capacity.  For example, when the large ocean-going submarine Carraciolo was sunk by HMS Upholder off Sicily in early January, she carried only about 160 tons of supplies on board.

Italian air force frontline strength throughout Crusader

The following information is similar to that provided for the German side in this post and is based on Santoro’s not particularly satisfying L’Aeronautica Italiana Nella II Guerra Mondiale published in the 1950s. Unfortunately the Aeronautica Militare Italiana’s historical office is busy churning out pretty coloured books with aircraft drawings instead of getting on with a proper operational study of the Regia Aeronautica in World War II. But hey, a man’s gotta work with what he has got, so here it goes.

At the end of the 1941 section of this book, Santoro has inserted some data which is very interesting.  Unfortunately he does not provide loss data for the period by month, but only in total between 7 February and 31 December, so I won’t bother with that here.  For the table below, which shows average effective (serviceable) frontline strength, I have included September as starting date since it was fully outside the Crusader air offensive.

The list is quite interesting, in that it gives a nice overview of the high variety of types present with the Regia Aeronautica, and the relative weight.  It is also interesting to note that average frontline strength did not drop very much in November compared to October, but crashed in December. This was probably related to the loss of landing grounds east of El Agheila.

Of particular interest is the reduction of 50% of the availability of G.50 fighter planes, indicating either a withdrawal (which I think unlikely), or the complete inferiority of the type (which I think is more likely) and high losses in escort and ground attack operations.  On the other hand, the introduction of the very fine M.C.202 in November must have come as a shock to the Commonwealth fighter pilots.

The biplane Cr.42 is quite an interesting one – apparently it was used as escort (which appears madness to me) for Ju 87 dive-bombers (saner explanation – they were coming along as ground attack planes to give the attack more weight), and (far more sensible) for convoys for which it was quite well suited, because of its ability to keep a low speed and the good visibility provided by the open cockpit (thanks to Jonas for those points).

Average Monthly Frontline Strength Sept - Dec 41

Average Monthly Frontline Strength Sept - Dec 41

The impact of air operations

A discussion on the AHF (linked here) allows us to track individual unit strength of Luftwaffe (GAF) units during the campaign.  This is based on three snapshots, on 11 October (before Coningham’s air campaign in support of Crusader started), on 27 November (from an ULTRA intercept, after more than a week of operations), and on 27 December, after the retreat from Tobruk and the fall of Benghazi.

There are some important observations to be made.  First of all, despite a major effort by the Allies, neither availability nor serviciability of the major types dropped significantly (with the exception of the Ju 88).  This is likely because of a major effort in reinforcement, bringing in additional flights and squadrons, especially of dive bombers and destroyers. For the Italian air force, I have some data, which will be posted in a separate post.

On 27 December the longer range planes had disappeared – in my view this is a reflection of the fuel situation, which made it pointless to keep planes in North Africa that could operate towards it from e.g. Crete.  It is very interesting to see the effect of reinforcement on the destroyer availability.  This is likely because these planes were used to protect convoys against air- and/or seaborne attack (with pityful results, one might add).

Overall these numbers tell an interesting story, but it may not be the one usually told.

The list is by unit, with the first number indicating planes present with the unit, and the second serviceable.

2. (H) 14 (specialised reconnaissance)

11 Oct 21/6 Bf 110C-4 and Hs 126

27 Nov (data not available due to communications breakdown)

27 December 20/12 Bf 110C-4 and Hs 126

I./JG 27 (single-engined fighters)

11 Oct 31/17 Bf 109E-7 Trop

27 Nov unchanged from day before (will eventually get to Kew where I hope they have this)

27 December 24/10 Bf 109F-4

II./JG 27 (single-engined fighters) minus 6./JG27

11 Oct 28/13 Bf 109F-4 Trop

27 Nov 19/12 Bf 109 F-4 Trop

27 December 24/10 Bf 109F-4 Trop

Staff ZG 26 (twin-engined destroyers)

11 Oct (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

27 Nov 2/2 Bf 110C

27 December (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

7./ZG 26 (twin-engined destroyers)

11 Oct (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

27 Nov 9/8 Bf 110C

27 December (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

8./ZG 26 (twin-engined destroyers)

11 Oct 12/8 Bf 110D-3

27 Nov 7/5 Bf 110C

27 December (not available)

9./ZG 26 (twin-engined destroyers)

11 Oct (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

27 Nov 5/4 Bf 110 C

27 December (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

III./LG 1 (twin-engined medium bombers )

11 Oct 31/15 Ju 88 A-4 Trop

27 Nov 27/2 Ju 88 (with 3 more aircraft in Derna after diverting)

27 December (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

I./StG 1 (single-engined Stukas)

11 Oct 39/26 Ju 87 B-1

27 Nov 27/18 Ju 87 + 1 Cant. 445

27 December 32/17 Ju 87 B-1

II./StG 1 (single-engined Stukas)

11 Oct 31/26 Ju 87 B-1

27 Nov 26/17 Ju 87 R-2/4

27 December  (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

Staff StG 3 (single-engined Stukas)

11 Oct 7/2 Ju 87 B-1 and He 111 (twin-engined medium bomber)

27 Nov 3/? Ju 87 R2/4 + 3/? Bf 110C + 4/? He 111 H5/6 + 1/? Bf 108 (liaison)

27 December  9/5 Ju 87 B-1 and He 111 (twin-engined medium bomber)

I./StG 3 (single-engined Stukas)

11 Oct (not available – unit may not have been in theatre)

27 Nov 26/23 Ju 87 R2/4

27 December 30/18 Ju 87

Additional information for 27 November:

10 KG zbV 1 (Transport)
Ju 52 12/0 with 4 aircraft on operations

Liaison Flight JG27(?)

No information

Staff flight Fliegerführer
Me 110C 1/0

Fliegerführer
Ju 52 1/0
C 445 9/0
FH 104 1/0
Me 108 1/0
Fi 156 1/0

Desert Rescue

Fi 156 8/4 of which 1 in Benina, 3 in Derna

The table below is based on the numbers above, but is not 100% accurate.  I calculated this myself. Note that the 27 November number for the Bf 109 type is understating the issue, since the data was missing from the ULTRA intercept. Also note that qualitatively the Bf 109 underwent an improvement during the battle, with the I./JG27 reporting 31 ‘Emils’, an earlier type of the Bf109, while by 27 December they reported 24 BF 109F, a much improved type, which was superior to anything the Commonwealth forces fielded in the North African theatre at the time. This of course depends on the 11 October type info being correct, something which I am having serious doubts about (it is apparently from RIng & Shore “Fighters over the Desert”.

Availability chart for major types in Africa during Crusader

Availability chart for major types in Africa during Crusader