The war in North Africa is often seen as having taken place on the ‘perfect battlefield’. Space for maneuver, no civilians or settlements to get in the way. Histories of the war consequently focus on the events on this ‘perfect’ battlefield, the to-and-fro of the tanks, and the battles in the air. This means that there is a serious gap in the historiography of the campaign that tore through Libya several times between June 1940 and January 1943. This gap is less of an issue for the Tunisian campaign.
There are also other issues relating to war crimes of course, including the systemic abuse of prisoners of war, repeated bombing of military hospitals, and some at least questionable actions in the heat of battle, but these should probably be considered part of the military, rather than social history.
The Topography of War
While Libya was (and is) a relatively empty country, it wasn’t depopulated. During the war, about 800,000 people are estimated to have lived there, with about 20% or so of them Italian settlers, and the remainder Arabs from various backgrounds, as well as an African population in the south of the country. While sparse compared to the size of the country, the topography meant the population was concentrated in settlements on the coastal strip, where a living could be eked out, or in various oases along old trading routes, depending on the presence of sufficient water.
These locations were, by their nature, important militarily and became targets of enemy attacks. They sat astride desert tracks that could be used for flanking maneuvers, and/or they were important logistical or military centers in their own right, such as Benghazi or Tripoli. Major centres were bombed regularly, sometimes nightly, and in the case of Tripoli also came under fire from the sea. While the targets were military, the nature and technology of night-time bombing in the early 1940s meant that in reality the whole settlement became a target.
La Domenica del Corriere cover 1912. Arab soldiers surrendering during the Italo-Turkish war. (Ebay)
The brutal History of Colonisation
The war was the second calamity to befall Libya in the space of just over a decade. During the 1920s into the early 1930s, the Italian armed forces waged a brutal campaign against the Senussia, a tribal insurgent movement aiming to throw off the colonial power. It was so violent that it earned its military leader, later Marshal Graziani, a convinced fascist, the nickname ‘The Butcher’.
Estimates are that as many as 10-15% of Libya’s population was killed in this campaign, the vast majority of them in Cyrenaica, where losses may have been as high as a third of the population. In the end, the Arab population was forcibly removed from their homes, and put into internment camps. The famous ‘wire’, the barbed wire fence on the Libyan/Egyptian border, still visible today, served to control the movement of these Arab insurgents across the border.
Domenica Dell Corriere cover, 1938. Italian colonists arriving in Libya. (Ebay)
The embers of this conflict remained hot, and when they were exposed during the campaign in Libya, it reignited. Arabs took sides, formally as part of the Libyan Arab Force on the side of the Empire, or informally in the form of irregular combat activity, sniping retreating Axis formations, or informing the British army’s Long Range Desert Patrol about Axis movements and strongpoints.
The consequences of these actions for those executing them, when they were caught, were no different in North Africa than they were in White Russia, Yugoslavia, or on Crete. Summary execution, destruction of property, brutalization of communities. This suppression was undertaken in full view and with the tacit or open agreement of the German co-belligerent forces.
Omar Mukhtar, Leader of the Senussi uprising, executed by the Italians in 1931. (Wikipedia)
Persecution of Libyan Jews
There was also a Jewish population group in Libya, who were at first not too badly affected by the Italian colonization project, but with the increasing radicalisation and racism of Italian fascism began to suffer from the late 1930s, and from 1941 onwards also were put into internment camps, where many of them perished. The idea that the Holocaust did not extend to the ‘clean war’ of North Africa is but a myth.
The main camp was the concentration camp at Giado (modern Jadu), just south-west of Tripoli, established 7 Feb 1942, just after the end of the military operations of winter 1941/42. The death rate in the camp was 21%, due to malnutrition and disease. There is no evidence that any killing by guards other than by neglect took place. The camp has its own entry on the US Holocaust Museum site at this link. Little is known about what went on there however. It was liberated by Empire troops in the middle of January 1943.
In late summer 1941, an unknown number of Libyan Jews with British passports were sent to Italy, where they were held (amongst others) at the concentration camps of Villa Oliveto and Bagno a Ripoli, near Arezzo. There is a site that has some information on them at this link. After the armistice they were briefly free to go, but chose to stay in camp. Most of them were eventually deported to Germany, where they ended up in Bergen Belsen.
More background on the persecution of Jews in North Africa can be found at this link. It appears that while initially, Governor Italo Balbo aimed to protect the Jewish community, following his death and the eventual appointment of committed fascists such as Graziani and Bastico, the situation deteriorated substantially in 1941.
Civilian Casualties and the War in North Africa
More directly, the war killed civilians as well, as elsewhere. These civilian casualties in North Africa seem to have occurred due to two primary reasons, first the air campaign by both the Axis and the Empire air forces, and secondly the violent suppression of insurgency against the Axis forces and that insurgency itself, which targeted not just Axis military personnel but also civilians. Murder, rape and violence were not uncommon.
I suspect that unlike e.g. in Normandy, few civilians would have been caught in ground combat activity. There is no comprehensive study on this aspect of the war available that I am aware of, but work is being undertaken on this, e.g. by Patrick Bernhard at the University of Oslo (see e.g. here). But the absence of a comprehensive piece of work makes it possible for us to keep thinking of this war as a clean one.
Nevertheless, the bombing campaign against Axis logistics centers caused substantial civilian casualties in relation to the size of the population, and it is documented in the war diary of Italy’s Comando Supremo, where of course casualties are neatly divided between Arab and Italian (Nazionale) dead. One example with heavy casualties is of 25 October, during an attack on Misurata, where the Arab quarter is hit, with 35 killed and 47 wounded. The war diary noted they were mostly muslims, with only one Italian killed.
Further documentation can be found in German war diaries from rear area installations, such as the Naval Transport Offices in Benghazi and Tripoli, which document air attacks as they are known in these offices, including a heavy attack on Benghazi on 14 October 1941, during which the civilian supply office is hit and 28 Arabs are reported as killed.
But the war diaries also reveal outright war crimes, such as the reported execution by Italian forces of 300 Arabs for sniping on retreating Axis troops on 22 December 1941, as Benghazi is abandoned, or the summary execution of two Arabs in March 1941, accused of cutting signaling wires at Misurata. While these numbers seem small, they need to be seen in the context of a population that was merely 1/60th of the UK population on 1939. So the two raids referred to above equate to attacks killing over 3,000 civilians during the Blitz. To take an example, the infamous Coventry raid of November 1940, which coined the word ‘coventrisieren‘ in German, claimed the lives of less than 600 people.
Filling a Gap
The lack of a comprehensive social history of the war in North Africa is a major gap in the historiography of World War 2. I truly hope it will be filled soon.
 Another source says July 1941.
BENGHAZI, LIBYA. 1941-12-26. BOMB DAMAGE CAUSED BY R.A.F. RAIDS ON THE CITY. AWM 022684
False. It was extended by German attempts. It is also sloppy at least to talk about internement camps and link them to Holocaust. Not all internment camps were linked to it.
“There was also a Jewish population group in Libya, who were at first not too badly affected by the Italian colonization project, but with the increasing radicalisation and racism of Italian fascism began to suffer from the late 1930s, and from 1941 onwards also were put into internment camps, where many of them perished. The idea that the Holocaust did not extend to the ‘clean war’ of North Africa is but a myth.”
It was the Italian Army that defended the Libyan Jews first from the Libyan Arab pogrom like attempts when Italy declared war against Allies thinking it was open season on Jews.
It was also Italian Army and in this case -contrary to what happened in Lybia- also Arab population in Tunisia, that protected Jews from the German SS Walter Rauff that arrived in late 1942. It was Admiral Luigi Biancheri that blocked most attempt by Germans to round up the Jews and send them to Germany. Those that could be transported were in some Luftwaffe transport aircraft.
Click to access 158511880921_Nico.Pirozzi.Gino.Biancheri.pdf
I’m sorry if this is uncomfortable for you, but the history is quite clear. Racial laws were applied before the Germans came. Many Libyan jews perished in Giado concentration camp (you can call them ‘internment camp’ if you want to, it’s just semantics. The Italian administration in Libya was complicit in this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jews_of_Libya_during_the_Holocaust#Giado_concentration_camp
That is not my point.
I know racial laws were applied before Germans came. Since 1938. They were nevertheless under rising German influence including cultural in a Fascist movement that was going stale.
Italo Balbo resisted them and even went in Rome with Jew friends in public. he also voted against it in the Fascist council.
The General naval engineer that designed the Italian battleships of Littorio class and which from his name came the anti torpedo defense system Pugliese (Umberto) was a Jew and was ordered to leave the Navy. When Taranto attack occurred a specific law had to be made to allow Jews to serve in critical positions.
There are degrees of difference even in racism and not all racist motivated violence and malnourished is linked to Holocaust.
The Giado concentration camp was setup in 1942. It was not a concentration camp to send Jews to Europe to be exterminated. it is not just semantics.
There were also Jew camps in Italy – not even of Italian Jews – for example an hundred plus survivors of a ship that was wrecked near Rodi in Dodecanese, they were sent to Italy to a concentration camp – Germans could not get them.
The difference that you call semantics can be a difference between being murdered or not, it is noticeable that the French Jews went to Italian Occupation Zone in Southern France instead of staying in the Vichy controlled zone.
Campo di Concentramento is the Italian term. It is the same in German or English. It’s the normal term for these camps, which differed from the destruction camps (Vernichtungslager) like Auschwitz in that they were not built to systematically carry out genocide. But the death rate was still 21% and neglect by the Italian authorities was the cause for this. If these people had not been sent to Giado, they would most likely not have died. Here’s some background reading on the camp. https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=8nBTDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA529&lpg=PA529&dq=campo+di+concentramento+giado&source=bl&ots=OKbzHMXnwG&sig=ACfU3U2OVH1my4IB6J9OCfO8vrpJfdhJFQ&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjN1dffsb3qAhUrVRUIHd34DrE4ChDoATAAegQIBxAB#v=onepage&q=campo%20di%20concentramento%20giado&f=false
“But the war diaries also reveal outright war crimes, such as the reported execution by Italian forces of 300 Arabs for sniping on retreating Axis troops on 22 December 1941, as Benghazi is abandoned,” can you give the reference for this ? Source ?
It’s the war diary of Naval Transport Office Benghazi, held at NARA and the German Federal Archives in Freiburg. PG / 45221 – 45228 entry for 22-12-41, time-stamp 2130 hours.